Folio

Important VC Fund Performance Metrics - IRR, MOIC, TVPI, RVPI, and DPI Explained

Cover: VC Fund Performance Metrics: IRR, MOIC, TVPI, DPI Explained

VC fund performance is read with five numbers because no single one answers every question: IRR for speed, MOIC for the size of a gain, DPI for cash returned, RVPI for value still on paper, and TVPI for the two together. Read them together, on the same basis and the same date. Without that, two funds with the same 1.80x TVPI look equal when one has returned nine times as much cash.

This applies when the fund is closed-end and calls capital from committed investors. Evergreen funds and deal-by-deal structures may need adjustments that this article does not cover.

Summary

  • Read five numbers together: IRR, MOIC, TVPI, DPI and RVPI. Always split TVPI into DPI and RVPI, because TVPI = DPI + RVPI.
  • Compare numbers only when they share a basis (net or gross), a level (deal, fund or LP) and an as-of date.
  • Pair every multiple with IRR. The same 2.0x is a 26.0% IRR over 3 years and a 10.4% IRR over 7.
  • From year 4, run a markdown test: cut NAV by 30% and recompute TVPI. In the worked example, Fund B falls 0.51x and Fund A 0.27x. If TVPI was 1.0x or higher before the cut and falls below it, treat the fund as at risk of returning less than paid-in.
  • If RVPI is more than 75% of TVPI after year 8, ask the GP for the exit plan within 30 days.
  • Ask for net IRR with and without any subscription line.

What are VC fund performance metrics?

VC fund performance metrics are the ratios that turn a fund's cash flows and valuations into comparable numbers. Five do most of the work: IRR (the rate), MOIC (the deal multiple), and TVPI, DPI and RVPI (the fund multiples measured against paid-in capital).

What they are not

  • Not a forecast. They describe cash flows and valuations to a date. A fund's final result can differ.
  • Not one score. Each metric answers one question. A single "best" metric hides the rest.
  • Not audited facts. Anything unrealised (RVPI, and so TVPI) rests on the manager's valuation.

What does each metric measure?

Each metric measures one thing: how fast (IRR), how much on a deal (MOIC), how much in total (TVPI), how much in cash (DPI) and how much still held (RVPI). Agree the definition and basis before comparing any two numbers.

MetricFormulaAnswersCommon error
MOICValue of a deal ÷ capital invested in it. Usually gross, before fees and carryHow many times did this investment multiply?Setting a gross deal MOIC against a net fund TVPI
IRRThe annual rate that sets the net present value of all cash flows to zeroHow fast did capital grow?Comparing IRRs on different bases, or reading an IRR built mostly on unrealised value as final
DPICumulative distributions ÷ paid-in capitalHow much cash has come back?Judging a young fund on DPI alone
RVPIRemaining NAV ÷ paid-in capitalHow much value is still held?Treating it as received
TVPI(Cumulative distributions + NAV) ÷ paid-in capital = DPI + RVPIHow much total value per unit paid in?Reading TVPI without its DPI and RVPI split

Paid-in capital is the cash the fund has actually called from investors, not the commitment. When portfolios in a composite have committed capital, provision 5.A.4 of the CFA Institute's GIPS 2020 Standards for Firms requires a firm that claims compliance to present TVPI, DPI, RVPI and the PIC multiple, which is paid-in capital divided by committed capital. What an exit pays out depends on the company's terms, and an exit waterfall model shows how much of a sale reaches each class of shareholder.

What changes between gross and net, and between fund and LP?

Gross figures are before fees and carried interest, net figures are after them, and a fund-level number is not an LP's own number. In our view, a net fund TVPI and a gross deal MOIC should never be ranked against each other.

  • Basis. Label every figure net or gross. ILPA's Performance Template v1.1 gives two calculation methods, Granular and Gross Up, and should be used for funds commencing operations on or after 1 January 2026.
  • Subscription lines. ILPA's June 2020 guidance asks managers to show net IRR with and without the use of the facility, with a clearly defined methodology. It is a follow-on to ILPA's June 2017 guidance, which also suggested LPs request levered and unlevered IRRs in diligence.
  • Level. Deal, fund and LP numbers each answer a different question. Say which one you are quoting.

Checking basis, level and date on every figure gets slow across several funds and LPs. For VC funds, family offices and LPs, Folio's portfolio metrics module covers performance reporting for funds and their LPs. See portfolio metrics in Folio.

Why does a multiple need an IRR beside it?

A multiple says nothing about timing, and an IRR says nothing about how much was gained, so each needs the other. Take a single investment of 1 that returns 2. Held 3 years, the IRR is 2^(1/3) − 1 = 26.0%. Held 7 years, it is 2^(1/7) − 1 = 10.4%. The MOIC is 2.0x both times.

This is why a fund's multiple tells you less about a manager's speed than its IRR does.

How do you compare two funds with the same TVPI?

Two funds with the same TVPI can hold very different amounts of cash, so split TVPI into DPI and RVPI before comparing. The example is illustrative, and both funds are in year 9.

As of the same date, $MFund AFund B
Paid-in capital100100
Cumulative distributions9010
NAV (remaining value)90170
DPI0.90x0.10x
RVPI0.90x1.70x
TVPI = DPI + RVPI1.80x1.80x
RVPI as a share of TVPI50%94%
TVPI after a 30% NAV markdown(90 + 63) ÷ 100 = 1.53x(10 + 119) ÷ 100 = 1.29x

Both funds show 1.80x, so a reader looking only at TVPI sees a tie. The split shows that Fund A has already returned 0.90x in cash and Fund B 0.10x. Fund B's RVPI is 94% of its TVPI, which is above the 75% default in the rule below, so it triggers the rule. After the 30% markdown, Fund A's TVPI falls by 0.27x and Fund B's by 0.51x. Neither fund falls below 1.0x after the markdown. An investor choosing which of the two to commit to again, on these suggested defaults, should prefer Fund A unless Fund B's GP can show a dated exit plan.

[Figure 1: Same TVPI, very different cash]

The rules below are suggested defaults, not industry standards. Set your own and write them down.

CheckSuggested defaultResponseBy when
Cash shareRVPI is more than 75% of TVPI after year 8 of the fundAsk the GP for the exit plan and the valuation basis for the top holdingsWithin 30 days of the report
Markdown testFrom year 4, cut NAV by 30% and recompute TVPIIf TVPI was 1.0x or higher before the cut and falls below it, treat the fund as at risk of returning less than paid-inAt each quarterly report
BasisAny pair of figures with a different basis, level or as-of dateDo not compare. Ask for the matching figureBefore comparing two figures

Running the markdown test every quarter for several funds is repetitive work. For VC funds, family offices and LPs, Folio's portfolio metrics module covers performance reporting for funds and their LPs. See how portfolio metrics work in Folio.

Which VC fund performance metric should you read first?

Read TVPI and IRR first in a young fund and DPI first in a mature one. In our view, this follows from timing: early value is mostly unrealised, while late in a fund's life the cash returned is what counts.

Fund age (suggested)Read firstThen check
Years 1 to 3TVPI trend and IRRRVPI basis: who valued the holdings, and when
Years 4 to 8TVPI split into DPI and RVPIMarkdown test
After year 8DPICash share rule: RVPI above 75% of TVPI, and the markdown test

LPs and family offices tracking fund investments should compare net figures and ask the GP for the basis. GPs should report net and gross side by side and label each.

When do VC fund performance metrics mislead?

These metrics mislead when the basis, the valuation or the timing is hidden. In each case below, change the figure you quote instead of quoting the headline.

SituationWhat to do instead
Gross deal MOIC next to a net fund TVPICompare deal with deal, or net with net
IRR with no note on a subscription lineAsk for net IRR with and without the facility
High TVPI, low DPI, late in the fund's lifeApply the cash share rule and the markdown test
Young fund with TVPI below 1.0xRead the trend, not the level. ILPA's glossary explains the J-curve effect: fees and start-up costs are paid from the first drawdowns, so a private equity fund will initially show a negative return
Numbers with different as-of datesDo not compare. Restate to one date

Known limits of this approach

  • Every unrealised number depends on the manager's valuation, and valuation methods differ by stage and market. The markdown test shows sensitivity, not the true value. A down round at a portfolio company is one real event that can cut a holding's value.
  • The 75%, 30%, year 8 and 30 days defaults are house suggestions. A fund with a longer planned life may need different ones.
  • Figures in different currencies are not comparable until restated to one currency and one date.

Fund metrics checklist

Before comparing two figures

  • Same basis: both net, or both gross
  • Same level: deal, fund or LP
  • Same as-of date

Every quarterly report

  • TVPI split into DPI and RVPI
  • Net IRR shown with and without any subscription line
  • From year 4, markdown test: NAV cut by 30%, TVPI recomputed. Treat as at risk if TVPI was 1.0x or higher before the cut and falls below it
  • After year 8: is RVPI more than 75% of TVPI? If yes, ask the GP for the exit plan within 30 days
  • MOIC used only within a deal, never against fund TVPI

Run this from one place. The checklist works in a spreadsheet, but it gets harder with every fund and every LP who joined at a different time. For VC funds, family offices and LPs, Folio's portfolio metrics module covers performance reporting for funds and their LPs. Copy the checklist above, then see portfolio metrics in Folio.

FAQ

Is XIRR different from IRR?

XIRR is an IRR that uses the actual date of each cash flow, which suits funds that call and return capital on irregular dates. Microsoft describes Excel's XIRR function as returning the internal rate of return for cash flows that are not necessarily periodic, and points to its IRR function for periodic ones. When a firm that complies with the GIPS standards calculates money-weighted returns, provision 2.A.29 requires it to use daily external cash flows.

Why is my fund's TVPI below 1.0x in the early years?

A TVPI below 1.0x means the fund reports less total value than it has called. Early on, the management fee and start-up costs are paid from the first drawdowns without adding equivalent value, and returns start to rise once the first realisations are made. That is the J-curve effect in the table above. In our view, read the trend across several quarters rather than one figure.

What is a good TVPI or IRR?

No single figure is good on its own. In our view, compare against funds of the same strategy and vintage, on the same net or gross basis, and read the five metrics alongside the LP reporting metrics that matter beyond IRR. A headline figure with no vintage and basis is not a benchmark.

Should an LP calculate these metrics itself?

In our view, yes for DPI, RVPI and TVPI, because they need only paid-in capital, distributions and NAV from your own capital account statements. Then compare with the GP's figures. A gap often points to a different basis, level (fund or LP) or date; check those before calling it an error.

Do the metrics change if my currency differs from the fund's?

Yes, once you convert. A fund usually reports its multiples and IRR in its own currency. If you convert each cash flow into your currency at the rate on its date, exchange-rate moves change the result. Our suggestion is to read each fund in its own currency first, then restate both to your currency on one date before comparing them, and show the currency effect on a separate line.

About Folio

Folio is Incentiv's fund platform for private market investors: VC funds, family offices and their LPs. It covers deal flow, portfolio, LP and fund management. Its portfolio metrics module covers performance reporting for funds and their LPs. Explore portfolio metrics in Folio.

Thresholds and response times are editorial suggestions, not financial or legal advice. All fund figures are illustrative.